By Jeff Meisner E-Commerce Times
10/22/08 2:48 PM PT
Samsung has withdrawn its bid for memory chipmaker SanDisk, which snubbed the $26 per share offer even as its stock value tanked. Samsung's move came two days after SanDisk's announcement of a $155 million third-quarter profit loss. SanDisk fell to less than $10 per share on news that the deal was dead.
eMarketer Whitepaper: Optimizing the E-Commerce Experience
From the Web to the Contact Center, are you prepared to proactively engage and keep your savvy customers? Read how e-commerce leaders are optimizing their sites with ratings, reviews, live help, Web analytics, mobile and more.
Shares of memory chip maker SanDisk (Nasdaq: SNDK) plummeted nearly 31 percent to US$9.91 per share after the bell on the news that Samsung has dropped its offer to acquire the troubled Milpitas, Calif.-based semiconductor company.
Korea-based Samsung first made its $26 per share offer six months ago in a letter to SanDisk's board of directors, which rejected it as too low.
Samsung's decision to rescind its offer follows SanDisk's financial results announcement on Monday. SanDisk reported a third-quarter loss of $155 million, which was well below Wall Street expectations. The company attributed the loss to a massive glut of semiconductors in the memory chip market.
SanDisk also announced on Monday a deal to sell 30 percent of its manufacturing capacity to joint-venture partner Toshiba for about $1 billion, a move designed to decrease its exposure in the memory chip market and shore up its balance sheet.
SanDisk's memory chips are used in a variety of consumer electronics devices -- mobile phones, MP3 players and digital cameras, just to name a few.
Is the Dance Really Over?
Despite Wednesday's announcement, the possibility of a Samsung and SanDisk deal might not be quite dead.
"I don't think it's over," Doug Freedman, an equity analyst at American Technology Research, told the E-Commerce Times. "This is only Act 1. [Samsung] has an ongoing business relationship with SanDisk. Samsung pays SanDisk royalties for the use of its intellectual property."
That agreement expires in 2009, Freedman noted.
"Samsung isn't looking to acquire SanDisk for its memory capacity," he said. "When you buy memory capacity, you're buying equipment that has a useful life of three or four years. It's a depreciating asset. They're going to have to come to some kind of agreement regarding their royalties relationship in the next nine to 10 months."
What Samsung Really Wants
Samsung is already the No. 1 maker of memory chips, which makes it unlikely it's after SanDisk's manufacturing capacity.
What Samsung really wants is SanDisk's intellectual property, Freedman said.
"Clearly, Samsung thought SanDisk's intellectual property was important enough to make an offer in the first place," he observed. "I think the market has completely missed that point. You've got the No. 1 guy trying to take out a competitor to get its IP."
However, given the resistance to a deal put up by SanDisk's board, Samsung may have to appeal directly to shareholders in order to get a deal done.
"I think over the next nine months, there will be more activity along this line," said Freedman. At the end of the day, the decision may rest in the hands of SanDisk's shareholders.
Facebook's Other Founder Goes Off to Found Some More October 06, 2008
Two of Facebook's top people are leaving the company to start their own company, which will focus on an open source enterprise productivity suite. Dustin Moskovitz was Mark Zuckerberg's roommate at Harvard when the two founded Facebook together in 2004. A top engineer is also leaving for the same venture.
Related Stories
SanDisk, Toshiba Deal Addresses Memory Chip Glut October 20, 2008
Toshiba is taking over a major portion of the manufacturing operations of SanDisk in a billion-dollar deal that could have a significant impact on competition in the memory chip space. Whether the deal makes a Samsung takeover of SanDisk more or less likely is the question.
Same Song, DRM-Free Medium: SanDisk Sells Albums on Memory Cards September 22, 2008
SanDisk is launching a line of memory cards containing full albums without DRM that play at a high-fidelity bitrate of 320 kilobits per second. Will the public buy into the idea of a physical storage medium in this age of downloads?
SanDisk Shakes Off Samsung's Second Shot at Takeover September 17, 2008
Samsung is looking to take advantage of weakness in the flash memory market to acquire SanDisk at a fire sale price. SanDisk has spurned its offers, but how long it can hold out, given the company's poor financials and the dire state of the overall U.S. economy, is the $6 billion question.
Related News Alerts
More by Jeff Meisner
AT&T Launches Netbook-With-Service Experiment April 02, 2009
AT&T is plugging a new plan in Atlanta and Philadelphia, offering netbook computers for as little as $50 to consumers who sign up for a monthly broadband access plan at $60 a month or more. The deal might be especially attractive to mobile workers in the healthcare and financial services sectors, who need more than a smartphone to conduct their business.
Microsoft Offers Small-Biz Server Value Meal April 01, 2009
Microsoft has unveiled a budget-minded server package for small businesses, providing the hardware, software and administrative services necessary to run their operations in much the same way that larger enterprises do. The offering could provide some competition for cloud-based hosted services, which have been gaining traction.
New Google VC Fund on the Prowl for Great Ideas March 31, 2009
Google is pouring some of its millions into a new venture fund on the lookout for innovations, particularly in the consumer Internet, software, clean tech, biotech and healthcare arenas. The move may seem counterintuitive during a recession, but Google argues that "great ideas come when they will."
Headline Feeds
to sell 30 percent of its manufacturing capacity to joint-venture partner Toshiba for about $1 billion, a move designed to decrease its exposure in the memory chip market and shore up its balance sheet.
Talkback: 
