By Jeff Meisner E-Commerce Times
09/17/08 4:00 AM PT
When he couldn't find what he wanted to buy online, Arash Fasihi decided to start his own e-commerce business to meet the demand. Things didn't quite turn out as planned, but four years later, the Canadian entrepreneur's brainchild, Cymax Stores, is edging up on $50 million in annual revenue.
eMarketer Whitepaper: Optimizing the E-Commerce Experience
From the Web to the Contact Center, are you prepared to proactively engage and keep your savvy customers? Read how e-commerce leaders are optimizing their sites with ratings, reviews, live help, Web analytics, mobile and more.
Finding a quality television stand on the Internet should be pretty easy in this day and age of Google (Nasdaq: GOOG) and Amazon.com (Nasdaq: AMZN), but back in late 2003, it wasn't.
Especially if one lived in Vancouver, British Columbia, like e-commerce entrepreneur Arash Fasihi did.
"I wanted a high-end BDI TV stand," Fasihi told the E-Commerce Times. "I was able to find it online, but no one would ship it to Canada."
That's because even as late as 2003 -- years after Amazon.com and other e-tailers started shipping consumer goods all over the world -- Canada was still far behind in its e-commerce evolution. Most Canadians didn't buy their furniture online.
That gave Fasihi, a 33-year-old Iranian immigrant, an idea: Create an e-commerce Web site that would let Canadian consumers easily find and purchase furniture and other items online.
It didn't happen. Here's what did happen, though: Fasihi and his wife, Shima, 27, started
Cymax Stores, which sells bedroom, office, living room and entertainment furniture.
This year, Cymax will bring in about US$48 million in revenue, Fasihi said, with 99 percent of that coming from customers in the United States.
One Web Site
Fasihi, who has a computer science degree from the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, launched the first Cymax e-storefront in 2004. Today, the company has 115 e-storefronts and about 100 employees. Cymax's e-storefronts offer consumers more than 250,000 items.
By the end of 2008, Fasihi expects to have a total of 200 e-storefronts that will bring Cymax into new retail segments such as consumer electronics, baby products, outdoor furniture products, kitchen and cookware products, and home appliances.
The company is also looking to open a 20,000-square-foot warehouse somewhere in the eastern U.S. to streamline the procurement and fulfillment processes.
However, getting Cymax launched back in 2004 wasn't that easy.
"It was easy for me to create the Web site," Fasihi said, "but getting the shipping and fulfillment stuff done was hard because we're a Canadian company."
Fasihi recounted one instance early on, when one of Cymax's furniture suppliers wouldn't open an account for the startup because of its Canadian address.
"So, we had to open a cash account where we paid in advance for our inventory, and we wired them money every week," he said. "After a few months, they gave us a credit line. It happened that way at the beginning with everyone. It got easier as we built a credit history."
Today, Cymax has relationships with furniture factories and outlets that make it much easier to get consumers the products they order on time, Fasihi said.
Not Another Amazon
What sets Cymax apart from e-tailing behemoth Amazon.com is its large group of different e-storefronts. Amazon.com employs a similar strategy but to a much lesser extent. For example, Amazon.com has an online storefront for shoes called
Endless.com, whereas Cymax has its 115 different storefronts.
"It's like a roll-up strategy where someone buys a bunch of bricks-and-mortar furniture stores to get a broad footprint out in the marketplace quickly," Sucharita Mulpuru, an e-commerce analyst with Forrester Research, told the E-Commerce Times. "[Cymax] is conglomerating all the traffic going to these various sites while using the same back-end infrastructure in the hope it can get more online real estate."
NetShops.com,
Niche Retail and
CSN Stores all employ the same strategy as Cymax, thus making them closer competitors to Fasihi's small company than Amazon.com.
However, the way Cymax differentiates itself most from its competitors -- including a giant like Amazon.com -- is by offering premium selection and customer service.
"I don't think there's a whole lot of value in being the cheapest," Mulpuru said. "Selection is the big value proposition online, and service is a big consideration, especially for furniture. It's important to provide rich customer service, telephone service, catalogs and guarantees that there will be reasonable delivery time frames."
Amazon.com, Mulpuru said, isn't going to do any of those things.
"Amazon usually defers to their inventory partners when there's a customer service issue," she said.
Amazon.com has a customer service line, Fasihi noted, but "there isn't any way for customers to call in and get specific information about products on Amazon because it has so many sites that sell products through the Amazon site."
Cymax, on the other hand, has an active customer service line, and Fasihi said his employees know which products they are responsible to know front and back.
It's Not Easy Being Small
Even with an expected $48 million in sales this year, Cymax is small compared to its competitors, Forrester's Mulpuru said.
"In the Web world, [$48 million in sales] would put them in the top 500 retailers," she said. "It's not tiny, but it's not significant either, in terms of some of the enormous e-tailers out there today."
One of Cymax's biggest challenges is making itself heard over the din of other e-tailers in the marketplace.
The startup spends "millions of dollars" every year on pay-per-click and sponsored search terms on search engines like Google and Yahoo (Nasdaq: YHOO), as well as other major shopping channels, Fasihi said.
A recent search under the terms "TV stands" and "beds" on Google brought up results that link to Cymax-owned stores --
Bedroomfurniturenmore.com and
Audio-Video-Furniture.com. Those results appeared at the very top of the results list.
"We keep close track of the keywords people use to search for products on Google," Fasihi said.
Meanwhile, Fasihi hasn't given up hope on the Canadian market, even though it accounts for just a fraction of sales at Cymax today.
"The Canadian market will be a big market for us, and we think it will gain in market share," he predicted.
Very interesting, especially that $48mil isn't that large anymore for an e-tailer. I would be ...
Next Article in Startups to Watch
GoodGuide.com Gives Up the Goods on Goods' Goodness September 12, 2008
A new startup, unveiled at the TechCrunch 50 conference, has caught the attention of the media and investors alike. GoodGuide is a Web site that categorizes consumer items and rates their "goodness" -- factors such as environmental impact and its manufacturer's social responsibility.
Related Stories
Three Special Ingredients for a Great Cross-Channel Loyalty Brew July 31, 2008
You can't have a great cross-channel marketing program without the right marketing automation technology, advises Neolane EVP Patrick McHugh. That said, the right system is not enough. Tech-savvy marketers also need to take into account a slew of variables that will help to make each loyal customer feel valued, appreciated and well-served.
Homing In on the Healthcare Consumer's Needs June 20, 2008
The Internet may be a vast data repository, but when it comes to smart targeting, there apparently isn't enough of the right kind of content to soak up all the advertising dollars businesses want to spend. The time is ripe for the emergence of vertical ad platforms, and the healthcare industry is a good place to start.
Fulfillment: The Unexpected Key to Successful E-Commerce February 11, 2008
Fulfillment operations should not only be fast and efficient in the DC -- they should increase speed and efficiency of the downstream distribution process. For example, e-commerce fulfillment operations should be able to palletize orders with delivery truck routes in mind, and orders should "picked to plan-o-gram" of destination stores -- without additional capital expense, labor content or cycle time.
Related News Alerts
More by Jeff Meisner
AT&T Launches Netbook-With-Service Experiment April 02, 2009
AT&T is plugging a new plan in Atlanta and Philadelphia, offering netbook computers for as little as $50 to consumers who sign up for a monthly broadband access plan at $60 a month or more. The deal might be especially attractive to mobile workers in the healthcare and financial services sectors, who need more than a smartphone to conduct their business.
Microsoft Offers Small-Biz Server Value Meal April 01, 2009
Microsoft has unveiled a budget-minded server package for small businesses, providing the hardware, software and administrative services necessary to run their operations in much the same way that larger enterprises do. The offering could provide some competition for cloud-based hosted services, which have been gaining traction.
New Google VC Fund on the Prowl for Great Ideas March 31, 2009
Google is pouring some of its millions into a new venture fund on the lookout for innovations, particularly in the consumer Internet, software, clean tech, biotech and healthcare arenas. The move may seem counterintuitive during a recession, but Google argues that "great ideas come when they will."