By Keith Regan E-Commerce Times
12/08/03 8:02 AM PT
"Companies should keep a low profile with regard to their Linux installations over the next few months," Gartner analyst George Weiss told the E-Commerce Times, noting that SCO has set a February deadline for launching additional lawsuits against Fortune 500 companies with extensive Linux deployments.
A federal judge in Utah has given The SCO Group 30 days to respond to demands that it reveal more information about the proprietary Unix source code it claims IBM (NYSE: IBM) infringed when Big Blue contributed Unix code to the Linux platform.
The judge ruled in favor of motions filed by IBM, which is seeking to force SCO to offer additional information about how IBM allegedly breached a SCO contract.
IBM claims SCO has provided it with nearly 50 CDs containing thousands of pages of source code, without any specific guidance as to which portions of code might have sparked SCO's multibillion-dollar lawsuit against IBM. SCO initially filed the lawsuit last March, seeking $1 billion, but subsequently upped its damages sought to $3 billion.
Hunt and Peck
According to transcripts of the court hearing posted on the Groklaw Web site, the judge agreed with IBM that SCO's decision to turn over some 900,000 pages of code did not provide IBM with adequate information to craft a defense in the case.
The judge gave IBM until Wednesday to draft a specific request and gave Lindon, Utah-based SCO until early January to respond.
IBM also asked the court to compel SCO to detail how each piece of disputed code represents an alleged breach of contract.
Legal observers said it is possible that SCO could appeal the ruling, although a more likely scenario would be for the company to make some attempt at compliance. IBM then might ask the court to dismiss the charges if SCO's response is not detailed enough.
More Conflict Looms
Meanwhile, research firm IDC said the battle raging among IBM, SCO and the open-source community will be a major high-tech story throughout 2004. IDC said it expects IBM to extend the same type of indemnification to its customers that HP (NYSE: HPQ) unveiled earlier this year in the face of stepped-up legal action from SCO.
For his part, Gartner (NYSE: IT) analyst George Weiss told the E-Commerce Times that Linux users must be wary of SCO's pledge to spend at least US$9 million of the $50 million it recently raised on legal assistance.
He noted that SCO has set a February deadline for launching additional lawsuits against Fortune 500 companies with extensive Linux deployments.
"Companies should keep a low profile with regard to their Linux installations over the next few months," Weiss said. "It may not be prudent to be out publicizing what you're doing with Linux right now."
Conspicuously Absent
The federal judge, meanwhile, put on hold requests by SCO to compel IBM to turn over any code that it contributed to Linux that originated from the Unix platform.
Observers noted that SCO's newly hired high-profile lawyer, David Boies, was not present at the hearing, a possible sign that SCO felt it might lose the early preliminary battle. SCO instead was represented by Kevin McBride, the brother of SCO's CEO, Darl McBride.
SCO CEO Defines, Defends Legal Strategy November 19, 2003
Aberdeen Group research director Bill Claybrook, who likened SCO's legal setup to "a hired gun to go out and kill people in the Old West," said SCO's latest statements are simply an extension of threats the company has already made. "Every time SCO elevates this, they become more hated," Claybrook told TechNewsWorld.
SCO Steps Up Legal Fund, May Fight Novell-SuSE Deal November 18, 2003
"By far the most important asset of this company is our ownership of the UNIX operating system, and today we are investing in the protection and future of UNIX," SCO CEO Darl McBride said.
SCO Files Subpoenas To Summon Stallman and Torvalds November 13, 2003
"If they continue doing things like this until the lawsuit goes to court in 2005, they will have everybody not liking them," Aberdeen Group research director Bill Claybrook told LinuxInsider. "There won't be anyone left that doesn't hate them."
SCO Claims Linux GPL Is Unconstitutional October 28, 2003
Phil Albert, a partner with law firm Townsend and Townsend and Crew, called SCO's claims about the unconstitutionality of the GPL "weird," telling TechNewsWorld that it will be tough for SCO to argue that the license is not valid. Albert said SCO is "shooting [itself] in the foot" with its response to IBM's counterclaims.
Rethinking the IBM-SCO Imbroglio October 23, 2003
Whether SCO's actions constitute "a scheme" and whether SCO is intentionally using FUD are currently arguable issues. In contrast, the allegation that this is about "a very old Unix" capitalizes on a widespread misunderstanding of the issues and represents FUD-slinging at its finest.
Related News Alerts
More by Keith Regan
Yahoo Slaps Fresh Coat of Gloss on Microsoft Deal Defense June 30, 2008
With its shareholders meeting set to take place in less than five weeks, Yahoo has put together a 32-page presentation, emphasizing why the investors should vote to keep the current board in place. The company also reiterated why it chose to partner with Google instead of letting Microsoft buy part of it.
French Court Stings eBay With $63M Judgment Over Knockoff Sales June 30, 2008
eBay is planning to appeal a ruling by a French court that ordered it to pay $63 million to the luxury goods maker Louis Vuitton Moet Hennessey. The court also barred the online auctioneer from selling four brands of perfume on its Web sites accessible in France.
New Auto Loan Leads Marketplace Shifts Into Drive June 30, 2008
Reply.com's move into the auto finance market is a logical one the company, as automotive advertising spending is moving online in increasingly greater amounts. The company is partnering with the Detroit Trading Company to create a massive repository of auto finance leads online.
Headline Feeds
Talkback: 
