Exchanging Real Money in Virtual Worlds

During the last few years, so-called virtual worlds have evolved. Second Life is a prominent example — with a registered user base targeting the 10 million mark. Avatars (virtual personalities) build virtual houses, purchase virtual goods and engage in electronic transactions.

Conducting business in these virtual worlds is only possible by implementing an efficient payment environment, which includes the introduction of a virtual currency and payment mechanisms.

Creating a Payment Environment

The concept of a virtual currency has to be created to allow for trading within the virtual world. Second Life has introduced Linden Dollars; Cyworld trades in Acorns; and World of Warcraft users pay for their transaction with virtual gold. In addition, an efficient payment mechanism has to be installed within the virtual world to make transactions possible.

It has to be defined how the virtual currency can be acquired, for instance, by buying the virtual currency with real money or by earning it within the world. Second Life, for instance, installed a currency exchange that is called “LindeX.” Users can easily exchange real money into Linden Dollars and vice versa. At the same time, Linden Dollars can be earned within Second Life by selling virtual goods. It is informative to analyze why Second Life has introduced its own currency and free convertibility to real currencies.

Analyzing Virtual Worlds

A virtual world can be described as a computer-based simulated environment that allows its users to live in this world and to interact with each other through avatars. The hype about the virtual world Second Life has quickly eclipsed other virtual worlds. However, online games like “World of Warcraft,” relationship platforms such as Cyworld and other platforms like Active Worlds are notable alternatives. Here’s a rundown on these three:

  • “World of Warcraft.” The massively multiplayer online role-playing game has become very popular since its launch in November 2004. It counted more than 9 million subscribers in the first half of 2007. It is embedded in the fantasy world of Azeroth. Avatars in different characters compete against each other within this game.
  • Cyworld. It is an online community that allows users to interact with real-word friends and to form new friendships. Your avatar “Minime” has the chance to join clubs and other special places. Various other features like the “Minihome” (dedicated personal space) and the “Miniroom” (chatroom) enable further interaction. Cyworld was launched in South Korea in 1999 and has currently millions of members across the U.S., China, Japan, Korea and Taiwan.
  • Active Worlds. It is the pioneer platform that allowed users to build their own virtual worlds and landscapes. It was founded in 1997. In the last quarter of 2007 it has reached over 2 million individual users worldwide. However, the technology of Active Worlds is older than the technology of Second Life and related platforms. Therefore, features like design and interaction are limited.

A Second Life Case Study

The development of a new payment mechanism within virtual worlds is influenced by consumer/business needs and generic factors. As a consequence of this, a new virtual currency and exchange were created within Second Life. The following factors generally play a role:

Illustration: Drivers for creating a newpayment mechanism in virtual worlds(click on image to enlarge)

Second Life’s virtual currency can be bought and exchanged from and to many real life currencies. The exchange service is globally available and exchange transfers can be easily affected for instance with a real world credit card or from an Internet wallet account. Once Linden Dollars are purchased, these can be spent within Second Life. By applying a wallet principle, the risk of overspending and monetary implications of fraud activities are greatly reduced.

This solution is cost-efficient for the consumer, as “real world” payment instruments and corresponding costs are also decreased. The consumer feels more closely affiliated with the community as the game character is fostered. Finally, the virtual currency has to be convertible to real world currencies, which allows the consumer to retract the money from the virtual world at any time. In summary, consumers are motivated to use the virtual currency and are retained as active participants.

Sellers profit from this concept and exchange fees are paid to Linden Lab instead of paying additional interchange fees. The payment and exchange mechanism allows sellers and Linden Lab to derive revenue from the virtual economy while minimizing costs. This is an important success factor for a virtual world.

The Generic Factors

For the Second Life payment and exchange mechanism to remain stable, it is important to retain its user audience and the trust of the community in the virtual currency. For some users, it may be money that they never intend to retract from the virtual world. However, Second Life millionaires such as Anshe Chung eventually want to reap their virtual gains in the real world.

Regardless of the services offered in the virtual world, it is apparent that introducing a virtual currency and exchange is simply the most cost efficient way of handling a high volume of low-value transactions. However, this will only work if the critical user mass is achieved and if the exchange rate remains stable. Alternatively, the payment mechanism within the virtual world can be designed as a closed-loop environment that allows purchasing virtual money but does not allow to covert it back to the real world currency anymore.

Paying Up

Payments within Second Life are made by exchanging virtual currency from one user to another user. These virtual transactions are supported by the innate programming logic of Second Life, which is administered by Linden Lab. Thus, users do not have to use credits cards or other real world payment instruments. However, some companies plan to issue virtual loyalty cards that would grant the users discounts when shopping at certain places within Second Life.

Before Linden Lab announced a policy change at the beginning of the year, users had also been able to bring their money to virtual banks to gain interest. Money could be paid in and paid out by using virtual ATMs.

Some banks offered annual interest rates of up to 60 percent per year. Since some in-world banks failed paying funds to customers — and the virtual bank Ginko Financial even went bankrupt in August 2007 — complaints of residents accumulated. As a consequence of these developments and in order to protect its subscribers, Linden Lab banned in-world banks from the community. Effectively, a virtual world also needs certain regulations and banking rules to stabilize its economy and to avoid enormous risks caused by unregulated institutions. Linden Lab’s recent decision is a reasonable step to regain the trust of numerous Second Life residents and potential subscribers.

Cashing In

Other virtual worlds often do not try to imitate the real world by installing ATM machines and banks. However, the payment mechanism is usually supported by the service provider’s own platform. For instance, in “World of Warcraft,” virtual gold is exchanged to pay for goods and services.

In order to derive revenue from a business in a virtual world, such as Second Life, real world production factors have to be applied. A financial investment is initially required to establish a budget in the virtual world. Know-how and time have to be invested to buy and design property/products, which in return can be sold for a profit. The below depicts a simplified illustration.

Illustration: Funding and extracting money into and from virtual worlds(click on image to enlarge)

From a payment point of view, money should be fundable and extractable from the virtual world at any point in time. Credit cards are usually used to convert real money into the virtual currency in order to fund the account. In addition, increasingly more Internet wallet type of payment instruments are used to fund virtual accounts. The exchange rate generally depends on the demand and supply of the virtual currency — although certain arbitrary seller aspects exist.

In Second Life, virtual money can be extracted through the official currency exchange or independent providers. In these cases, Internet wallet type of payment instruments are suited to receive the credit in real world currency. Real world payment instruments are thus only used for entry and exit transactions, which greatly reduces fraud risks and fees which would otherwise be charged for many small micropayments.

However, some variations to this model exist. For instance, “World of Warcraft” gold is not officially sold through the platform provider but it’s sold on eBay. Some companies have specialized in generating gold within the virtual world and then to sell it for real world currency. However, an official exchange rate mechanism does not exist and is not intended by the game provider.

Other worlds, such as Cyworld, allow for exchanging real money into virtual money but not vice versa. Thus, only the platform provider and its affiliated partners sell virtual products. Participants are not drawn to this world to make a profit but for the community aspect.

The future will show how the business models will develop in the virtual arena. From a payment and legal perspective, the situation is certainly more complex when money can once more be extracted from the virtual world. As the virtual money has a certain value in the real world, it has to be determined if a bank license is necessary to safeguard and exchange the money. Furthermore, restrictions have to be in place with regard to the maximum exchange amount in order to fight money laundery transactions — or certain businesses types such as casinos have to be banned from the virtual world due to local laws that do not permit that profit is derived from that.

Critical Business Factors

Businesses who intend to derive profit from a virtual world have to have a successful business model and give consideration to the payment mechanism adapted in the virtual world. Here’s a summary of what companies need to know:

  1. A multitude of virtual worlds exist and correspondingly different revenue and payment methods.
  2. The platform provider of the virtual world should allow for extracting the virtual currency.
  3. Payment transactions within the virtual world are predominantly low value (micropayments). It may thus take time before a considerable amount is accumulated to exchange it to a real world currency.
  4. An efficient and secure payment mechanism has to exist within the virtual world.
  5. Real payment instruments have to be used to fund money to the virtual bank account or to extract money. These payments instruments are often restricted to credit cards and Internet wallet type of payment instruments.
  6. Virtual currencies are subject to exchange rate fluctuations. In principle a demand/supply principles determines the exchange rate, however, certain arbitrary aspects also exist. The risk to invest money in a virtual currency is less foreseeable than investing in a real currency.
  7. Regulations and laws such as money laundering laws restrict the conversion amount from virtual money into real money. In some countries local laws do not allow to profit from gambling activities.

Andrea Kaminski is vice president of international finance and managing director for Arvato Finance Services, a provider of financial management solutions. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of Arvato (part of Bertelsmann).

1 Comment

  • I can only speak on the Activeworlds platform, but I know one of the biggest problems we have had in developing an internal currency system within the community is producing one that can be used in a uniform fashion.
    Few unified data sources exist and each world wants its own system.
    The other major problem is that while people invest a lot of time and money into the AW platform community wise the paid trade element is limited to a handful of specialist modelers, programmers and artists.
    Typically the internal economies of the platform are based on trade, rather than a paid fee. This does encourage certain aspects of the community but users expecting to come in from SL and make a few hundred $ from making a few objects will be shocked to find they can’t.

Leave a Comment

Please sign in to post or reply to a comment. New users create a free account.

E-Commerce Times Channels