By Erika Morphy CRM Buyer Part of the ECT News Network
05/05/07 4:00 AM PT
Sooner or later, the spotlight will move away from Judge Roy Pearson Jr. and focus on how he was able to get this far with his complaint. Then, consumer advocates -- and, yes, litigators -- worry that a public backlash could develop against the protections in place for consumers.
How Much is 'Free' Costing You? Learn how DaveRamsey.com saw a 567% uplift in ROI with Omniture. This complimentary guide and webinar cover the most important factors in selecting an analytics solution. Download Now.
It is not easy -- actually, it is close to impossible -- to find anyone who is sympathetic to Roy Pearson Jr.'s position. Pearson has made headlines in recent days for his eye-popping US$65 million suit against his dry cleaners. This is not a tort about, say, environmental negligence that caused Pearson injury or illness. No, the man is suing Custom Cleaners for
misplacing a pair of his pants.
Pearson, a judge, is reportedly hinging his lawsuit on the promises expressed in two signs that used to hang in the Washington, D.C., store: "Satisfaction Guaranteed" and "Same Day Delivery." He is taking advantage of Washington's consumer protection laws, considered the strictest -- or the best, depending on your point of view -- in the country, which allow him to levy such huge fines.
Using the Legal System
Right now, though, the focus is on the judge himself. "Sixty-five million dollars! He is using the courts as a tool of legal harassment," said Bonnie Russell, a spokesperson for USAJudges, an organization that provides reports on individual judges. Pearson is up for another 10-year appointment, she noted.
"It will be interesting to see if he gets it," she told CRM Buyer. "His legal background shows that he is very clubby in an already clubby system."
Sooner or later, the spotlight will move away from Pearson himself and focus on how he was able to get this far with his complaint. Then, consumer advocates -- and, yes, litigators -- worry that a public backlash could develop against the protections in place for consumers.
"Through his pleading, the judge's stance appears to be that this suit is all about the betterment of customer service," said Ian Friedman of Ian N. Friedman and Associates.
"People, though, I believe, will have a difficult time accepting that argument because of the amount of money," he told CRM Buyer. "The money will shift the focus from a wrongdoing towards an individual attempting to get money."
Human Errors
Errors always occur during the course of doing business. "A human rate of error is inevitable," Friedman noted. That said, he does believe more accountability needs to be required of businesses that provide services to consumers.
The irony is that this lawsuit is likely to be used as a Trojan horse to dismantle existing consumer rights instead.
"As an issue, it would have been a good test case -- but is it ever the wrong case," he remarked.
Digg Encryption Uproar: All About the Right to Tinker May 04, 2007
What Digg did and didn't do in response to a HD DVD encryption-cracking code on its site is the subject of much controversy. By the thousands, Digg members jumped on the freedom of speech bandwagon, which gets closer to the heart of the matter -- that there's some fundamental issues at stake in the form of a 32-digit number.
Related Stories
Is Customer Support Triple Play's Albatross? May 04, 2007
As broadband providers introduce more complex services, there's a corresponding rise in what customers expect from the providers, according to a recently published report from Parks Associates. "The increasing numbers and types of value-added offerings paradoxically create greater expectations from the consumer for support and hand-holding," the report noted.
More by Erika Morphy
Ballmer Gives Shareholders - and Dell - Cause for Optimism November 20, 2009
Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer was all smiles at the company's shareholders meeting, as he touted the early success of Windows 7. Ballmer's cheer may have been contagious; after posting a massive earnings decline for the third quarter, Dell needed some good news to latch onto, and the prospect of broad enterprise adoption of Windows 7 could spur PC sales.
AA.com Sucks the Fun Out of Trip-Planning November 20, 2009
Using AA.com to book a flight was a painful experience. Densely packed, disorganized information was displayed in an unattractive format. On the plus side, it did seem as though the deals American Airlines advertised were real and not mere bait-and-switch lures. For anyone who wants a travel-planning Web site to inject a little pleasure into the experience, though, I say look elsewhere.
Salesforce.com Pumps Up Volume of Workplace Chatter November 19, 2009
Salesforce.com has developed a collaboration platform that puts social networking to work. Salesforce Chatter facilitates employee collaboration on projects through Facebook-like profiles, status updates, feeds and groups. The question remains whether employees will be as open to social networking in the workplace as they are in their personal lives.