By Fred J. Aun E-Commerce Times
07/24/07 1:33 PM PT
This is the second time a trio of former Harvard classmates has sued Facebook alleging its founder, Mark Zuckerberg, stole their code and used it to build his site. The first lawsuit, filed in 2004, was dismissed because of a legal technicality. Zuckerberg, who could become a billionaire before 30 if he sells the company, denies the allegations.
How Much is 'Free' Costing You? Learn how DaveRamsey.com saw a 567% uplift in ROI with Omniture. This complimentary guide and webinar cover the most important factors in selecting an analytics solution. Download Now.
A federal judge in Boston is set to hear arguments this week in a case that accuses Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg of stealing the code on which he built his massively popular Web site. The lawsuit could at least damage the young Web 2.0 entrepreneur's reputation, and at worst result in a Facebook shutdown.
Cameron Winklevoss, his brother Tyler and Divya Narendra filed the complaint against Zuckerberg, whom they asked to help them build a college social networking site when they were attending Harvard University.
The plaintiffs allege Zuckerberg undermined their effort and surreptitiously stole the source code, design and business plan. He went on to create Thefacebook -- as Facebook was initially called -- while the Winklevoss/Narendra project, called "ConnectU," floundered.
Facing Off Over Facebook
A judge at the upcoming hearing will hear the plaintiffs argue for a shutdown of Facebook and a transfer to them of Zuckerberg's assets. They also want extra money to be paid as damages.
The lawsuit alleges copyright infringement, the stealing of trade secrets, breach of contract and fraud.
The Winklevoss brothers and Narenda first sued in September 2004, but the complaint was dismissed due to a technical error. The allegations in the re-filed complaint remain substantially the same -- that Zuckerberg was an unpaid but full member of their site development team and stole the idea. The suit alleges business torts and unfair business practices.
Facebook has filed a countersuit alleging defamation.
He Never Looked Back
ConnectU did eventually get launched in May 2004, but it remains tiny compared to the wildly popular Facebook, which now has tens of millions of users.
Zuckerberg stands to be a twentysomething billionaire if he sells the site -- and he's had a number of offers, including a widely reported US$1 billion offer from Yahoo (Nasdaq: YHOO).
Some analysts believe the pending lawsuit will make it difficult for Zuckerberg to sell Facebook. Greg Sterling, a non-practicing lawyer who, as principal of Sterling Market Intelligence, is now a tech industry analyst, isn't one of them.
"I could pull out examples of litigants that have been acquired," Sterling told the E-Commerce Times. "The conventional wisdom is this creates some sort of cloud over the company. But I think Facebook is such a potentially desirable acquisition the lawsuit is not going to deter suitors. If anything, it might have a marginal impact on the final price but I don't think it's going to make somebody walk away."
Business as Usual
The lawsuit certainly didn't stop the creators of Mozilla's Firefox browser from agreeing recently to have their new company, Parakey, acquired by Zuckerberg. Sterling also noted a storm of copyright allegations against YouTube didn't deter its acquisition by Google (Nasdaq: GOOG).
Additionally, Sterling doubts a judge will shut down Facebook, even if the complaint is found to have merit.
"It's just not going to happen," he said. "There are a lot of situations where the law will not pursue a really Draconian remedy. It will try to provide a monetary remedy and there really is no reason why ... the site should have to be shut down."
While Zuckerberg is not exactly shrugging off the lawsuit, he isn't overly concerned about losing the case because "there is really good documentation of this: our code base versus theirs," he said in a New Yorker article that was entered into evidence in the case.
Facebook spokesperson Meredith Chin declined to comment on the case.
AT&T Beats Street, iPhone Numbers Cast Shadow on Apple July 24, 2007
Although AT&T's second-quarter earnings surpassed expectations, its results were overshadowed by data showing that iPhone sign-ups fell short of expectations. AT&T's net profit was $2.9 billion for the quarter, a 61 percent increase when compared with the previous year's quarter. The company's second-quarter revenue was $29.5 billion, an increase when compared with $15.8 billion in the same period a year ago.
Related Stories
Facebook Snaps Up Firefox Founders' Startup Parakey July 20, 2007
Facebook made its first acquisition, picking up Parakey, a startup founded by Blake Ross and Joe Hewitt, a pair who created Mozilla's Firefox browser. Although specifics about what exactly Parakey is are few, it is described as a way to bridge the gap between desktop applications and Web functions.
Facebook to Offer Big Cash Prizes for Best Apps July 11, 2007
Bay Partners is going to pony up the cash to fund 50 awards -- ranging from $25,000 to $250,000 -- for developers who come up with the best Facebook innovations. "Bay wants to find the killer apps, whatever they may be, for this new social OS," said Salil Deshpande of Bay Partners. "With the AppFactory, we will help entrepreneurs discover, build and monetize them."
MySpace Is Bart, Facebook Is Lisa June 26, 2007
MySpace tends to attract younger teens from lower-income families, and Facebook draws college and college-prep crowds, according to a recent report by Danah Boyd, a researcher at the University of California, Berkeley. Some of Boyd's observations are to be expected, as Facebook started off as a Web site for college students.
Related News Alerts
More by Fred J. Aun
Intel Feels Fury of OLPC Scorned January 09, 2008
"Over the entire six months it was a member of the association, Intel contributed nothing of value to OLPC," said OLPC. "Intel never contributed in any way to our engineering efforts and failed to provide even a single line of code to the XO software efforts even though Intel marketed its products as being able to run the XO software."
Yahoo Pumps Up Mobile Effort in Bid to Get a Jump on Google January 08, 2008
"Yahoo's ultimate goal is to bring the best possible Internet experience to the billions of mobile consumers around the globe," said Marco Boerries, executive vice president of Yahoo's Connected Life division. "We believe that to succeed on such a scale, the best strategy is to open up our mobile platform in order to tap the innovation and talent of the world's developers and publishers."
Wikia's Search Philosophy: It Takes a Village to Challenge a Giant January 07, 2008
"What you see here is our first alpha release," says a greeting on the Wikia Search site. "We are aware that the quality of the search results is low. Of course, before we start, we have no user feedback data. So the results are pretty bad. But we expect them to improve rapidly in coming weeks, so please bookmark the site and return often."
Headline Feeds
Talkback: 
