By John P. Mello Jr. E-Commerce Times
04/27/07 7:43 AM PT
The ban on Internet gambling may soon be lifted -- that is, if the chairman of a powerful Congressional committee gets his way. "People have said, 'What is the value of gambling?'" stated Rep. Barney Frank, chairman of the House Financial Services Committee. "Here is the value: Some human beings enjoy doing it. Shouldn't that be our principle?"
Increase Customer Sales with VerticalResponse Email Marketing! Quickly and easily send email newsletters, coupons & sales announcements to your customers – no technical expertise needed. Sign up for your Free Trial today and send 100 emails on us!
The chairman of a powerful Congressional committee filed a bill Thursday that aims to repeal the ban on Internet gambling passed last year.
Rep. Barney Frank (D-Mass.), chairman of the House Financial Services Committee, filed the measure Thursday morning.
Frank has been a vocal opponent of the ban, which became law last October.
"I guess people think gambling is tacky," he said in the House during debate on the prohibition measure last July. "They don't like it. Well, fine, then don't do it. But don't prohibit other individuals from engaging in it.
"People have said, 'What is the value of gambling?'" he continued. "Here is the value: Some human beings enjoy doing it. Shouldn't that be our principle? If individuals like doing something and they harm no one, we will allow them to do it, even if other people disapprove of what they do."
Driving Business Underground
Since the ban became law, much online gambling has been driven underground, contended Michael Bolcerek, president of the 400,000-member Poker Players Alliance in Washington.
"It has driven the public companies and the most financially transparent companies out of the marketplace," he told the E-Commerce Times. "People are still playing, but they're playing with private companies offshore."
When regulations mandated by the law are finalized, he continued, even that channel will dry up. "What you will have left is the most unscrupulous operators," he said. "What is essentially happening is that the business is being driven underground."
Reflecting Reality
He advocated changing the existing law to reflect reality, not morality.
"Internet gaming is a fact of our Internet environment," he declared. "We need a realistic approach to ensure player safety and address public safety."
However, outright repeal of the law, which gained passage during the waning hours of last year's Congress when its provisions were stuffed into a bill on port security, will be difficult, according to Anthony N. Cabot, a partner in the Las Vegas, Nev., law office of Lewis and Roca.
"It's difficult for legislators from many areas to look like they're supporting gambling, so a wholesale repeal would be very difficult," he told the E-Commerce Times.
Improving the Law
A repeal bill, however, could be used as a vehicle to make the existing law more palatable, Cabot noted. The law could be improved by:
Removing requirements that the U.S. Treasury monitor payments for illegal gambling. "That's completely unworkable unless you want to spend billions of dollars coding every transaction that goes through the banking system," Cabot asserted.
Clarifying ambiguities in the law related to games of skill versus games of chance. If games of skill -- poker, chess, bridge and such -- were exempted from the law, Cabot estimated that an additional 25 percent to 30 percent of the market would be legalized.
Legalizing international horse race wagering. That move would square U.S. law with a decision by the World Trade Organization on the subject, Cabot explained.
Virtual Casinos at Home
Supporters of the ban, however, argue that it should remain untouched.
"It would be a huge mistake to repeal the law," David Robertson, Internet gambling specialist with the National Coalition Against Gambling Expansion in Washington, told the E-Commerce Times. "It has been very effective."
As evidence of that, he pointed to a recent failed deal between online gambling group 888 Holdings and bookmaker Ladbrokes. One reason given by the companies for termination of talks was the uncertain legal environment in the U.S.
"Internet gambling puts a virtual casino in every home where it's available, 24/7," Robertson maintained.
Given the support the ban has had in Congress in the past, "it would be absolutely astonishing if they even came close" to repealing it, he opined.
Alterations Likely
Even if it isn't repealed, the law could be substantially altered by lawmakers this year, according to Andrew Parmentier, a senior vice president with the Friedman, Billings, Ramsey Group, an investment bank.
"Momentum continues to build behind the scenes in Washington for a new licensing and tax regime that would govern Internet gaming and, in the process, supplant the UIGEA (Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act), which was signed into law last fall," he wrote in a research note released on Tuesday.
"The most important driver of gaming legislation will be that it could raise in excess of (US)$20 billion over five years," he argued. "Democrats are starved for 'revenue raisers,' as they have put in place 'pay as you go' budget rules that do not allow them to spend federal money unless they raise revenue or cut spending in other areas.
"Secondly," he added, "the political landscape has changed since the passage of last year's ban -- Democrats control the House and Senate, and conservative social Republicans no longer hold the sway they once did."
Linden Calls In FBI to Probe 'Second Life' Gambling April 04, 2007
The legality of virtual gambling in Linden Lab's "Second Life" is reportedly being investigated by the FBI. There are many casinos in "Second Life" offering poker, blackjack and slot machines. "The question is whether these avatars violate criminal statutes by illegally gambling in these cyberworlds," said technology attorney Raymond Van Dyke.
WTO Rules Against US Net Gambling Ban March 30, 2007
The U.S. ban on Internet gambling is not in line with international trade policy, the World Trade Organization stated Friday. In a 51-page ruling, the WTO dispute settlement board found that the U.S. had not taken steps to better align its own domestic regulation of gambling with its prohibition against U.S. residents placing bets at overseas-based Internet casinos.
More by John P. Mello Jr.
Learning the Way of the Snow Leopard November 23, 2009
When confronted with a new piece of technology, some users will jump right in, but others may want to learn from an expert how to get the most out of it. Class On Demand puts 13 lessons onto a DVD that Mac greenhorns can use straight from their new computers. However, as many vendors operating in the Apple universe have found, one of their biggest rivals may turn out to be Apple itself.
VMware Fuses Performance With Convenience November 16, 2009
Fusion 3.0, the latest virtualization app from VMware that lets Mac users run Windows alongside OS X, puts an emphasis on performance. VMware built it specifically to leverage the 64-bit capabilities of Snow Leopard with a new 64-bit native engine. Its Migration Assistant for Windows lets Mac switchers recreate their old Windows PC inside a Mac, file by file.
Mouse Meets Multi-Touch November 09, 2009
Apple's latest peripheral, the Magic Mouse, takes the concept of multi-touch that the iPhone and iPod touch popularized and merges it with a button-free mouse. As one's mouse is a direct point of contact between human and machine, any changes made to it can be a divisive issue. Some users love the new abilities Magic Mouse brings to the table; others just can't stand the thing.