After years of smooth sailing with antitrust regulators, IBM once again finds itself the target of accusations that it isn't playing fair in the marketplace. This time, the complaints have arisen over Big Blue's refusal to license its mainframe software. IBM argues that it has the right to protect its intellectual property, but smaller competitors say they're locked out of competition.
How Much is 'Free' Costing You? Learn how DaveRamsey.com saw a 567% uplift in ROI with Omniture. This complimentary guide and webinar cover the most important factors in selecting an analytics solution. Download Now.
The Justice Department is looking into allegations that IBM (NYSE: IBM) has abused its dominant position in the market for mainframe computers, the data-crunching heavy lifters of the computing world that IBM introduced in the 1960s, which are now used to process some of the most sensitive data in banking, government and healthcare.
The accusations stem from claims by IBM rivals that they've been illegally frozen out of the mainframe market because of IBM's refusal to allow its mainframe operating software to run on non-IBM computers. IBM doesn't have many rivals anymore that make mainframe computers, but some smaller companies are trying to develop technologies that would allow the software to run on cheaper hardware.
They allege that IBM, which used to license its mainframe software to competitors and for the back half of the last century operated under an antitrust agreement with the government, stopped doing so in recent years to choke off competition.
Lock 'Em Up
Known for their reliability, mainframes can cost US$1 million or more each and are behind many everyday transactions. Withdrawing cash from an ATM, for example, often involves the ATM pinging a mainframe at the bank where the customer's data is stored to make sure there's enough money in the account.
The
Computer and Communications Industry Association, which complained to the Justice Department last month about IBM's behavior, said Wednesday the government has started examining its allegations by sending out formal requests for information about the mainframe market to IBM rivals.
"IBM will tell big customers that if you buy that other stuff, we're not going to let that stuff talk to our stuff," said Ed Black, CEO of the trade group. "We think of the Internet as open and innovative, but that's a lock 'em up and keep 'em locked up strategy . That's very unsatisfactory for the customer base."
Expansion Thwarted?
One of the companies that received a request from the Justice Department was Tampa, Fla.-based
T3 Technologies, which in January lodged a formal complaint against IBM with European antitrust regulators and is suing IBM in the U.S. alleging antitrust abuses.
The company, a reseller of IBM mainframes from 1992 to 2002, says IBM has tried to thwart its expansion into making mainframes by denying it licenses for IBM's mainframe software, something done "for no reason other than to remove all competition from the mainframe market."
T3's president, Steven Friedman, didn't respond to messages from The Associated Press late Wednesday.
The Justice Department would not comment on a potential antitrust investigation.
Antitrust Agreement Phased Out
In a statement, IBM pointed to a decision last week by a judge in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissing T3's complaint against IBM.
"We understand the Department of Justice has asked T3 for documents from the litigation," IBM said. "We continue to believe there is no merit to T3's claims, and that IBM is fully entitled to enforce our intellectual property rights and protect the investments that we have made in our technologies."
Armonk, N.Y.-based IBM said it will cooperate with any inquiries from the Justice Department.
That case stems from a conflict between IBM and Platform Solutions, whose technology was used to run IBM's mainframe operating software on non-IBM computers. Platform had also complained to European regulators about IBM's conduct, until IBM bought Platform last year and the companies dropped their lawsuits against each other.
T3 had joined the case on Platform's side.
IBM's clashes with antitrust authorities go far back.
For nearly 50 years, the company operated under an agreement with the government that sought to limit IBM's power in certain markets. The agreement, a so-called antitrust consent decree, was struck in 1956 to settle allegations of monopoly abuse in the market for electronic tabulating machines. It also covered computers, and parts of it gradually phased out until all provisions were dropped in 2001.
The company's last clash with antitrust authorities was a 13-year fight that stretched from 1969, when the government filed a separate antitrust lawsuit against the company, until 1982, when the government dropped the case.
Feds Nab Dozens in Bank Phishing Scheme October 08, 2009
Federal authorities have cracked down on a theft ring that they say stole at least $1 million from bank customers using fraudulent emails. The group, according to the feds, would trick victims into giving up their online banking information by sending them official-looking emails that appeared to be from their bank, a technique known as "phishing." Egyptian authorities assisted in the investigation.
Related Stories
IBM Sets Up Shop in the Business-Apps Bargain Basement October 02, 2009
IBM is going after Google Apps with the launch of LotusLive iNotes, which offers Web-hosted business email, calendaring and contact management capabilities for just $36 per user per year. The annual per-user cost for Google Apps Premier Edition is $50. Microsoft offers an online business productivity suite for $15 per user per month.
IBM Corrals Desktop Management in the Cloud September 01, 2009
IBM has taken cloud-based hosting to another level with the announcement of a public desktop service that will allow customers to strip down their in-house infrastructures to bare bones. The product is not yet fully baked in terms of running all the high-end applications some desktop users might require. However, IBM intends to boost functionality as it continues to develop the service.
Must-Tweet TV: Television Gets Into the Social Media Mix August 31, 2009
Tech corporations and TV networks apparently see some star potential in Twitter. IBM has patented a TV remote that incorporates Tweeting and other social media features into the television-viewing experience. Meanwhile, a few Fox reruns will feature scrolling cast and director commentary courtesy of Twitter.
Headline Feeds
Talkback: 
