Welcome | Sign In
ECommerceTimes.com
News

U.S. Shuts Down Net Porn Billing Scam

Print Version
E-Mail Article
Reprints
U.S. Shuts Down Net Porn Billing Scam

The accused principals allegedly used adult Web sites as part of their billing scam.


eMarketer Whitepaper: Optimizing the E-Commerce Experience
From the Web to the Contact Center, are you prepared to proactively engage and keep your savvy customers? Read how e-commerce leaders are optimizing their sites with ratings, reviews, live help, Web analytics, mobile and more.

The U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) said Thursday it has charged an overseas company and its principals with billing consumers and attempting to collect payment for Internet-based adult entertainment services and international phone calls that were never purchased or authorized.

According to the commission, Verity International Ltd. and the other defendants also misrepresented that consumers were legally obligated to pay, regardless of whether the user actually accessed the services.

The consumers were also told that that they owed money for a remote Internet connection through Madagascar, when in fact the connection was made through a cheaper location, according to the commission.

Thousands of consumers were billed an average of $250 (US$) apiece, the FTC said.

Influx of Complaints

In addition to Verity, the FTC charged Integretel, Inc. of San Jose, California, and its eBillit subsidiary, along with Robert Green and Marilyn Shein of the United Kingdom.

The FTC said it received almost 600 consumer complaints in "a matter of days," beginning September 18th.

"When so many consumers call about one issue in such a short period of time, we not only take notice, we take action," said Jodie Bernstein, director of the FTC's Bureau of Consumer Protection.

Many consumers who complained to the FTC said they had no idea why they received the bills. Others said a minor in the household, or someone else who did not have the subscriber's authorization, accessed the adult Web sites and downloaded the Verity dialer software, according to the commission.

Statements from the Accused

Verity issued a statement through its lawyer, Joel Dichtler, asserting that its services "comply fully with all FTC and FCC guidelines" and that all charges, according to the company, are "clearly disclosed" before the dialing software can be downloaded.

The company added that it "desires to work with the FTC" to resolve the matter.

For its part, Integretel, as the company that forwarded the bills on Verity's behalf, was "caught in the middle" of the problem, said chief executive officer Joe Lynam. The company, he said, is talking to the FTC and expects to be removed from the case.

"It was Verity's product, Verity's service" that the bills covered, he said.

Dialing Without Authorization

The Web sites contained a dialer program that provided users with access to the adult site without verifying whether the user was the line subscriber, and the calls were made without asking the user to authorize charges for so-called "videotext" services, the FTC said.

Once the dialer software was downloaded, it disconnected the computer's modem from the user's Internet service provider and reconnected the consumer's modem to the Internet from some overseas location, opening at an adult Web site, according to the FTC complaint.

Consumers, the FTC said, were then charged $3.99 per minute for the remote Internet connection.

Thousands of Bills

Integretel, a service bureau and billing aggregator, sent more than 67,000 invoices through its eBillit subsidiary to consumers during the second week of September and 44,000 bills the following week, the FTC said.

Telephone customers who called Verity's toll-free number "found that it was nearly impossible to reach a customer service representative," the FTC said. Those who did get through were told that they were responsible for the charges, the commission said.

Court Freezes Assets

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York issued a temporary restraining order against the defendants, freezing their assets, the FTC said.

The commission voted 5-0 to file the complaint, which seeks restitution for the consumers, as well as "disgorgement of ill-gotten gains, along with any additional relief a court deems proper."

The UK's Office of Fair Trading, Ireland's Office of the Director of Consumer Affairs and the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission helped with the investigation, the FTC said.


Print Version E-Mail Article Reprints More by Nora Macaluso


Talkback: Join the Discussion.
Re: U.S. Shuts Down Net Porn Billing Scam
Robert DeGarmo
Posted 2001-10-08
How about unauthorized 900 calls to sex lines that route to an international long distance ...
See Related Stories
Auto Mega-Site Nets FTC Approval (09/11/00)
FTC Lowers Boom on Net Porn Scammers (09/08/00)
U.S. Cracks Down on Net Stock Scams (09/07/00)
FTC Seeks Global E-Commerce Laws (09/07/00)
FTC To Seek AOL Time Warner Concessions (09/05/00)
U.S. Busts E-Commerce Stock Scam (08/17/00)
FTC Backs Away from Net Privacy Regulation (07/28/00)
FTC To Block Toysmart Data Sale (07/10/00)
Feds Bust Massive 'Dot-Com' Stock Scam (06/15/00)
FTC, Industry Clash Over Online Privacy (05/23/00)
FTC Cracks Down on Net Health Scams (04/06/00)

More by Nora Macaluso

One Year Ago: Should E-tailers Drop Nasdaq Before Nasdaq Drops Them?
January 30, 2002
Once a company is kicked off the Nasdaq, its stock is listed on the over-the-counter 'pink sheets' for thinly traded issues.
Study: Europeans Ignore Potential of TV-Based Commerce
January 18, 2002
Interactive TV also provides retailers with the opportunity to draw attention to themselves using interactive ads, Gartner said.
The Amazon Earnings Speculation Story
January 21, 2002
For Amazon to break out of the box created by the competing objectives of boosting sales and controlling costs, a pro-forma profit in the fourth quarter will be critical, a Goldman Sachs analyst wrote.
Don't miss a story -- sign up for our FREE e-mail newsletters and view the latest headlines at a glance.
Tech News Flash [ View Sample ]
E-Commerce Minute [ View Sample ]
ECT News Network Weekly Newsletter [ View Sample ]
Shortcuts
ECT News Network Information
Reader Services
Corporate
ECT News Network