By Louis Columbus CRM Buyer Part of the ECT News Network
07/30/04 6:00 AM PT
But every CEO cannot be the Phil Mickelson of outsourcing. I suspect there are some Cinderella stories in there, but for the vast majority of them, getting either software or hardware outsourcing right takes lots of time, many hours of practice, and the patience of Job to make it all work out.
It's that time again; the earnings calls for CRM, ERP, hardware and services vendors are being scheduled, rehearsed and delivered to shareholders, industry and financial analysts. What's common across the more than two dozen calls I've listened to that span CRM, ERP and SCM software, hardware and services companies is that every CEO is offering up a spin on how global outsourcing is making their business even more cost-competitive, responsive to global markets and stronger for the strategic long run.
With all this apparent success at both software and hardware outsourcing, I began to feel like myself as a golfer, sizing up and playing Phil Mickelsons. In short, he has a great long game, a great short game, and I play badly on a good day even on a miniature golf course. But every CEO cannot be the Phil Mickelson of outsourcing. I suspect there are some Cinderella stories in there, but for the vast majority of them, getting either software or hardware outsourcing right takes lots of time, many hours of practice, and the patience of Job to make it all work out.
In short, nothing valuable ever comes free, and all these CEOs on conference calls this quarter tell you about the strong successes at outsourcing, forgetting to mention the curve of pain they have ridden, in some cases for years, to get this strategy right.
For companies outsourcing manufacturing, the course has been especially unforgiving and even brutal for some of them. Like strong winds that whip across the front nine at Pebble Beach, any change in quality assurance, manufacturing engineering, and even the smallest wisp of an Engineering Change Order (ECO) can play havoc with the lay of the ball.
Jack Welch Doesn't Give 'Mulligans'
As the calls went on, I realized that CEOs are giving themselves outsourcing mulligans -- a free shot sometimes given a golfer in informal play when the previous shot was poorly played -- and the leaders of hardware companies are the biggest culprits. Jack Welch said in his autobiography that he does not give mulligans, but then again he had Six Sigma to guide outsourcing production efforts -- in short, a great read of the course for manufacturing.
The real takeaways from earnings calls where outsourcing is proclaimed as the new success strategy are:
Software outsourcing really is delivering results. There is less of a variation between what's happening in these companies and the claims they make on their conference calls. There are several situations where outsourcing application development actually saved special pricing request, partner relationship management, order capture and even configuration strategies. Infosys, HCL and Wipro are learning from customers what works and what doesn't. Further, companies doing global outsourcing for software development had less of a variation between what their 10Ks at the SEC said and what the CEO said on the conference call.
Claiming manufacturing outsourcing worked the first time is like making an eagle putt with a wedge. Sure, it could happen, if you have the best read of the processes and have a very tight relationship with the outsourcer. But then again, the majority of the time this strategy is as tough as trying to clear a water hazard 100 yards from the tees. Tough to do without a solid approach strategy, lots of focus, luck, and perfect conditions. Just get another ball out now and prepare to swing again.
Meet your global outsourcing partner salesforce.com. It's a global playing field now, and outsourcing to salesforce.com fits with how so many companies work today -- this company has found a way to get into the productivity workflows of its customers. Being located in San Francisco versus Bangalore -- what's the difference? Isn't it all about value and usability delivered? It's time for companies to get over the global outsourcing paranoia and realize everyone has to compete at a global level every day to survive -- that's the new reality of outsourcing, it sharpens global competitiveness.
CEOs of hardware companies are giving themselves an extra drop. Any hardware company you track has an interesting story to tell about outsourcing right now. The most recent 10Ks filed with the SEC talk about the many costs and huge investment in outsourcing, yet the CEO talks about offshore manufacturing like it's effortless. Somewhere between these two extremes is the truth, and it leans more to going over engineering, quality, service and manufacturing processes over and over again like any golfer practices his or her swing. Outsourcing really is like golf. Like golf, companies struggle with performance and are anxious about little improvements. Like golfers, there is always a recasting of the toughest round in the best possible light.
Experience Curve
Across the board this earnings season, no one knows how many outsourcing mulligans CEOs of software, hardware and services companies took. But there is one certainty: Come next quarter after another round, the CEOs will all be back, and some might tell us about the experience curve they have been down and lessons learned. But for most, it will be a description of how they got their outsourcing strategy pin high. Nothing comes for free, and, especially for manufacturing companies, the lessons can be costly and enduring.
Bottom line: Outsourcing's allure is the same as golf: freedom to hit away and play the game as you specifically want to. Ironically both outsourcing and golf make you earn that freedom, and for hardware manufacturers, it's better to own up to your handicap now, and don't mulligan away the future. For software companies, outsourcing is like the course you always wanted to play -- and in the case of CRM, the path is proven and worth a round.
Louis Columbus, a CRM Buyer columnist, is a former senior analyst with AMR Research and is founder of LWC Research, a firm specializing in CRM, sell-side e-commerce, sales and product configuration and guided selling.
IntelliCare CRM Offers Nurses an Alternative July 20, 2004
"IntelliCare looks like it has a unique solution that would be interesting to tie to hospital automation systems for a complete view of the patient," Yankee Group program manager Sheryl Kingstone told CRM Buyer.
Related Stories
Outsourcing and Protectionist Rhetoric in the Senate July 09, 2004
Opsware chairman Marc Andreessen points out that, just as in agriculture, automation will make America more efficient and productive. "Manufactured goods will keep getting cheaper and more plentiful, manufacturing companies will get continually more productive, and jobs will be continually created in areas around manufacturing," he said.
Nortel Gives Up Manufacturing with Outsourcing Sale June 30, 2004
Nortel spokesperson Christina Warren told the E-Commerce Times that approximately 2,500 employees are impacted by the announcement, more than half of them in Canada. While she declined to say that employees would be given any guarantees about their status, Warren said they would all be given "the opportunity to transfer to Flextronics."
Outsourcing Customer Satisfaction April 24, 2004
Yankee Group analyst Phil Fersht told CRM Buyer that a great deal of hypocrisy revolves around businesses' decisions to outsource their help desks. "Companies talk about wanting to provide good customer service, but they're more concerned about cutting costs right now," he said. "Also, some companies get on their high horse and say they don't outsource to overseas companies, yet they outsource to companies that do."
Indian Outsourcer Infosys Establishes US Branch April 09, 2004
Infosys is not making the move to U.S. soil to be a pioneer in reverse outsourcing, according to company spokesperson Chelsea Hardaway. She told the E-Commerce Times that the firm's main intention is to provide affordable consulting services in the United States that can draw on India's productivity.
IBM Buys India Call-Center Firm for $170M April 07, 2004
"Companies that may have been reluctant to sign a deal with an Indian company, especially given the tenor of the debate around the issue, can now sign with IBM to outsource everything and then let IBM decide where the jobs go," industry analyst Ned May told the E-Commerce Times.
More by Louis Columbus
Don't Manage Your Channels by Crisis November 03, 2008
As businesses look for places to save money, one area many are considering is sales channels. Before you go and just cut loose your underperforming channel partners, however, see if you can get the relationship to work more efficiently, writes columnist Louis Columbus.
Social Networking: Still Challenged by Enterprise Complexity October 20, 2008
While many companies see the value of social networking on a conceptual level, they're having trouble integrating it into their enterprise IT workflows, writes columnist Louis Columbus. Developers, however, are looking for ways to make it happen.
Generating Leads in a Web 2.0 World October 06, 2008
Web 2.0 technologies have changed the way companies and their customers interact, writes columnist Louis Columbus. So, he advises, companies should update the message they deliver to their customers to take better advantage of this new conversation.
Headline Feeds
at both software and hardware outsourcing, I began to feel like myself as a golfer, sizing up and playing Phil Mickelsons. In short, he has a great long game, a great short game, and I play badly on a good day even on a miniature golf course. But every CEO cannot be the Phil Mickelson of outsourcing. I suspect there are some Cinderella stories in there, but for the vast majority of them, getting either software or hardware outsourcing right takes lots of time, many hours of practice, and the patience of Job to make it all work out.
Talkback: 
