By Martin Middlewood CRM Buyer Part of the ECT News Network
07/20/04 6:15 AM PT
"IntelliCare looks like it has a unique solution that would be interesting to tie to hospital automation systems for a complete view of the patient," Yankee Group program manager Sheryl Kingstone told CRM Buyer.
eMarketer Whitepaper: Optimizing the E-Commerce Experience
From the Web to the Contact Center, are you prepared to proactively engage and keep your savvy customers? Read how e-commerce leaders are optimizing their sites with ratings, reviews, live help, Web analytics, mobile and more.
Maine isn't normally considered a hotbed for emerging-technology entrepreneurialism. Yet that's where IntelliCare, a healthcare call center outsourcing company, started in 1997. By 1999, the company had put its Yankee pragmatism to work to create a distributed networking model for telephonic nursing driven by its own clinically based CRM application.
Today more than 250 healthcare organizations nationwide use its outsourcing contact centers, including Oakland's Children's Hospital, Magellan Health Services and Group Health Cooperative.
Nearly 80 percent of IntelliCare's contact center representatives are nurses working from home. Many are highly trained specialists with subspecialty expertise in specific disease states, like cardiac nurses specializing in congestive heart failure, diabetes nurses focused on patients with complex diabetes or a smoking-cessation specialist. Remote
working allows the nurses to blend their career with their families and
other interests.
Telephonic Nursing Emerges
Victor C. Otley III, CEO and chairman of the board, told CRM Buyer that the company was founded on the belief that nurse call centers, or telephonic nursing, provides a more cost effective and convenient means of
dispensing health information to patients.
IntelliCare's customers are large physician groups, hospitals, health systems, health plans, disease-management companies and other healthcare employers. To support them, the company has located data centers in Portland, Maine; St. Louis, Missouri; Dallas, Texas; Columbia, Maryland;
Bristol, Connecticut; and Buffalo, New York. The company says it plans
to expand its centers to at least three more around the country in the
near future.
Going for the Vertical
In the beginning, Otley explained, IntelliCare ran on a licensed CRM program that was a sort of nurse triage application. Then in 1999, the company developed a healthcare-specific CRM application that was clinically focused and deployed in a distributed operating environment in an ASP-like model.
"Overall, we have been saying for a long time that verticalizing CRM is the way to go," Esteban Kolsky, research director of CRM and e-business at Gartner (NYSE: IT), said to CRM Buyer. "We have seen many smaller and midsize vendors do very well in small niches," he said.
Kolsky explained that he didn't expect Siebel to be able to compete at the specific-function level like IntelliCare, but he does expect the company to win at the enterprise-function level, where integration, flexibility and
multiple functions are necessary.
Explaining that generic CRM packages don't seem to offer the specific clinical requirements needed, Otley said that this left a gap for his company to develop a CRM solution based upon the essential clinical guidelines, knowledge bases, workflows, documentation and quality auditing capabilities the healthcare market required.
For his part, Kolsky pointed out that vertical-centric applications are sometimes cheaper and better fitted than Siebel solutions and noted that the cost per agent for Siebel averages between US$1,500 to $2,000 or more depending on what modules are being used.
Converging Technologies
After seeing how generic teleservice companies struggled with telecommuting, Otley said that his company saw that the technology
required expensive investments in dedicated or fixed bandwidth circuits into a
home to create the infrastructure for supporting telecommuters.
That changed in about 1999 with improvements in network-based switching,
especially for the home-office market, and while it wasn't scalable, it
showed that telecommuting was plausible.
Because, IntelliCare's primary labor force was a registered nurse (RN),
who is professional and loyal, developing an infrastructure for remote
workers would benefit both. Otley explained that IntelliCare designed a PC,
network-based architecture that allowed its nurses to telecommute using
very low bandwidth and also that also supported the centralized quality
control and monitoring of the calls critical to the company.
Today, IntelliCare has migrated away from custom telephony solutions to
more standards-based systems to focus on its CRM solution according to
Otley.
Distributed Model Succeeds
Typically IntelliCare takes a brick-and-mortar contact center and rapidly deploys its distributed operating model by having the agents telecommute and
sometimes consolidating the space, moving customers from the traditional
contact-center approach to a virtual one or a combination of onsite and
remote services.
While many of the nurses provide their own PCs and phone headsets,
IntelliCare provides the infrastructure. The telephonic functionality
resides on a nurse's PC, and IntelliCare drives all the connections call
passing, recording and conferencing that are done as a part of the
standard workflow. A standard phone line handles voice, while a virtual private
network (VPN) sends data that meets Health Insurance Portability and
Accountability Act (HIPAA) requirements for security and patient
privacy.
Status Quo Is Competition
From the competitive view, Otley said he believes that the status quo -- people
running and operating their own centers -- is the major factor. Otley
stated that the company's healthcare-specific CRM application gives it a
competitive edge but that its distributed model is its real advantage.
He indicated that he thinks that as people become more aware of the quality improvements and cost reductions that a remote contact center offers, they are
increasingly receptive to outsourcing. "Typically we can save organizations 30
percent over their previous contact center costs," he said.
Yankee Group program manager Sheryl Kingstone said that the status quo
of in-house developed solutions is the biggest competitor for any CRM
solution.
"IntelliCare looks like it has a unique solution that would be
interesting to tie to hospital automation systems for a complete view of the
patient," Kingstone told CRM Buyer.
Nurses in High Demand
A study published by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services,
"Projected Supply, Demand, and Shortages of Registered Nurses: 2000-2020," says that there is a growing chasm between the demand for registered nurses and
the number of nurses graduating.
The study predicts that by 2005, the country will be short more than
149,000 RNs. And the problem worsens, because between 1996 and 2000 the
number of licensed RNs no longer employed in nursing grew by 52,000 to
more than 490,000 leaving an untapped pool of nursing professionals outside the
healthcare industry.
Because IntelliCare can tap into the existing pool of RNs who have left
nursing for one reason or another, IntelliCare's remote model has made
room for nurses now outside the industry -- for example, mothers who've
chosen to stay home with children and nurses in the later stages of their
careers, who have tremendous experience be don't want to drive or stand on their
feet all day.
To manage its staff, IntelliCare has a sort of bidding system for
scheduled slots. The company publishes a schedule of what it needs, the skills
required and when it is needed.
"The nurses describe their work with us as all the rewards of nursing
without the bed pans," Otley said.
Balancing Nursing, Motherhood
After graduating in 1998, Heather Kierstead spent two years working as
an RN in a hospital setting before coming to IntelliCare. When she worked
at a hospital, Kierstead was on a fixed shift. At IntelliCare, she says,
she works two 10-hour shifts from 5 p.m. to 3 a.m., which allows her to turn
childcare duties over to her husband when he comes home from work. "The
schedule is the most important thing to me as a working mom," she said.
Kierstead said that she her telephonic nursing work allows her to serve
patients better and at the same time balance a busy life as a mother of
three. She remarked that when she worked in a hospital, she would leave
some days feeling that she hadn't given the care she wanted to give
patients because she was busy completing all the required activities, like delivering medications, food and drinks to them.
"When I get a call, I can focus on one patient at a time, educate each, help each deal with their symptoms and feel that I've done my job as a nurse," she explained.
Reducing Healthcare Costs
When a patient call comes in, either an interactive voice response
front-end categorizes the call and routes it to the appropriate party,
or a non-RN screens the call to determine basic information for appropriate
routing.
Then an IntelliCare nurse can often redirect people who think they need
emergency room care to urgent care or even assure them that they can
wait to see a doctor the next day. Getting the patient to the right medical
resource at the right time helps reduce overall health care costs.
According to Robert Teolis, market analyst for St. James Hospital and
Health Systems, using IntelliCare has averaged the hospital a 50 percent
savings over the previous solution. He also said that overall
complaints have been quite minimal and that the hospital's toll-free number has proven to be an easy, convenient tool for patients.
Depending upon the IntelliCare service, a nurse subspecialist may handle a
dozen different outsourcing customers -- physicians' groups, health plans
or disease-management companies -- that are using a similar IntelliCare
program. In other cases, a nurse may only deal with one outsourcer,
depending upon call volume and staffing.
Company Growth
Last month, the company announced plans to acquire Buffalo, New
York-based NightCall Physician Services, which provides telephone nurse
triage services supporting 55 physician practices with after-hours calls for
patients and a 24-hour medical help line for Independent Health group
members. Currently NightCall receives 80,000 calls a year from
organizations it supports.
The company's press release says that IntelliCare will continue to
employ the local nurses and deliver daily around-the-clock medical
contact center services to Independent Health's 350,000 members as well as the
patients of participating physician practices. NightCall will be
IntelliCare's sixth medical contact center, and its first in New York.
The company also plans to extend services into other geographic areas as
well as other healthcare service areas.
"Because telephonic nursing improves outcomes, the federal government is
looking to expand the idea nationally across the Medicare population,"
Otley said.
"And we're looking at some of the chronic care improvements that the
federal government is endorsing, specifically the Centers for Medicare
and Medicaid Services," he said.
Outsourcing Customer Satisfaction April 24, 2004
Yankee Group analyst Phil Fersht told CRM Buyer that a great deal of hypocrisy revolves around businesses' decisions to outsource their help desks. "Companies talk about wanting to provide good customer service, but they're more concerned about cutting costs right now," he said. "Also, some companies get on their high horse and say they don't outsource to overseas companies, yet they outsource to companies that do."
Nobel Economist Praises IT Outsourcing March 31, 2004
"Global sourcing creates more jobs and higher real wages for American workers," ITAA president Harris N. Miller told TechNewsWorld. "Now we have the data that prove it."
ITAA Report: IT Outsourcing Benefits Economy March 30, 2004
Not everyone buys into the premise of the report. John A. Challenger, CEO of job placement firm Challenger, Gray & Christmas, told the E-Commerce Times that jobs are being outsourced faster than they can be replaced by startups and expanding firms.
The Other Side of Outsourcing: Dangers Offshore February 24, 2004
If you are going to outsource, define the tasks broadly and make the result a flat fee. Don't provide incentives for buying new anything. And, should they actually come in under budget, share the savings with them. That way they have incentive to save money.
To Outsource or Not To Outsource? June 17, 2003
An added benefit of outsourcing is that because of time zone differences, workers in India can function as a second shift, handling many of the demands that arise during U.S. off-hours.
Related News Alerts
More by Martin Middlewood
CarsDirect CTO Debra Domeyer on CRM December 25, 2004
One of our challenges is keeping up with the constant speed of change of the enormous amount of automotive data that we manage. CarsDirect has 120,000 different vehicle configurations all up on our Web site at the same time. The data that we provide on all vehicles, their pricing, configuration and incentives for vehicles changes constantly.
Keith Raffel of Siebel on Serving On-Demand CRM November 25, 2004
"OnDemand is almost like recombinant DNA. What's happening now is that the OnDemand model is being infused into Siebel's very DNA. It's no longer just an alternative. It's part and parcel of what we offer. It's not an extra. It's a critical part of Siebel's solutions for its current customers and its potential customers," Siebel OnDemand helmsman Keith Raffel told CRM Buyer in an exclusive interview.
CarsDirect CTO Debra Domeyer Addresses CRM July 26, 2004
One of our challenges is keeping up with the constant speed of change of the enormous amount of automotive data that we manage. CarsDirect has 120,000 different vehicle configurations all up on our Web site at the same time. The data that we provide on all vehicles, their pricing, configuration and incentives for vehicles changes constantly.