By Jay Lyman TechNewsWorld Part of the ECT News Network
04/09/04 10:27 AM PT
Forrester analyst Jan Sundgren told TechNewsWorld that with far fewer vulnerabilities and viruses than Windows, Mac users could be in danger with their guard down. However, Sundgren downplayed the threat of MP3Virus.Gen, adding that Mac OS X is not nearly as popular of a target for attackers who are looking to get an "explosive outbreak."
How Much is 'Free' Costing You? Learn how DaveRamsey.com saw a 567% uplift in ROI with Omniture. This complimentary guide and webinar cover the most important factors in selecting an analytics solution. Download Now.
The first reported malicious code to target Apple's (Nasdaq: AAPL) Mac OS X operating system, a potentially damaging Trojan Horse computer program, is serving as both a validation of the platform's security and a warning that more may be coming.
Announced by Mac security vendor Intego, the Trojan horse, dubbed MP3Concept or MP3Virus.Gen, exploits a weakness in Mac OS X where applications may appear to be other types of files, Intego reported.
The malicious code, or malware, is encapsulated in the ID3 tag of a digital music file, which are heavily used with Apple's popular iTunes online store and iPod player. While it is capable of playing music to help fool the user, the file is actually a hidden application that can run on any Mac running OS X, Paris-based Intego said.
Security experts agreed that the lack of antivirus and awareness on the part of Mac users could leave the alternative computing community at risk of an attack. However, they also agreed that there have been so few previous Mac viruses and there are so few targets compared to the Windows population, the Mac OS X operating system remains more secure.
"Do we need Mac users to get to the same level of awareness as PC users? The answer is no," iDefense director of malicious code Ken Dunham told TechNewsWorld. "The issue is the level of threat is not as great, not for Mac users."
Intego First Alert
Intego, which provides antivirus and other security protections to Mac users with its VirusBarrier software, said the MP3 Concept tricks the user by showing the malicious application as an MP3 file with icon and extension.
If users double-click the MP3 as with a typical music file, the hidden code is launched on the Mac and although it plays music contained in the file, it can damage or delete files, according to Intego.
"While the first versions of this Trojan horse that Intego has isolated are benign, this technique opens the door to more serious risks," said a company security alert, which added the Trojan had the potential to delete all of a user's files, e-mail itself to others and infect MP3, JPEG, GIF or other QuickTime files.
Dunham, who referred to code in his lab that purports to be Mac malware but has not been tested since security demands more focus on Windows, said any new Trojan for Mac OS X is noteworthy because there have been virtually no previous assaults on the platform.
"We may see problems in an area where we haven't seen them before," Dunham said.
Mac More Susceptible?
Since there have been so few viruses and worms that target Mac computers -- the AutoStart worm that caused sharp but temporary pain for users is among the only ones that stand out in recent history -- antivirus programs for Mac OS X are somewhat lacking both in availability and deployment.
"The conditions are more ripe in the Mac domain than it would be in others from the user not expecting it or being gullible," Dunham said. "What it means is if a traditionally safe platform becomes hostile, it could be extremely hostile in the early stages of an attack."
Forrester analyst Jan Sundgren told TechNewsWorld that with far fewer vulnerabilities and viruses than Windows, Mac users could be in danger with their guard down.
Not a Popular Target
However, Sundgren downplayed the threat, adding that Mac OS X is not nearly as popular of a target for attackers who are looking to get an "explosive outbreak."
Dunham, who said PC users from the home environment and up must be aware of and using security measures including firewall, antivirus and aversion to attachments, indicated that Mac users are still in a more secure environment.
"These users are going to not be as sieged as Windows users," Dunham said. They don't have to worry about the concerns of PC users."
Apple responded to the Intego security warning and said it is trying to address the issue quickly. "We are aware of the potential issue identified by Intego and are working proactively to investigate it," Apple said.
"While no operating system can be completely secure from all threats, Apple
has an excellent track record of identifying and rapidly correcting
potential vulnerabilities," the company added.
There are a few flaws in your theory. The main flaw being that for quite a few years now the ...
Next Article in Security
RealNetworks Warns of Remote Attack Danger April 08, 2004
Aberdeen Group vice president Jim Hurley said it is extremely difficult for media player vendors to test the security of their products on all of the various platforms on which they run. "It's almost impossible for one supplier to test all of the outcomes of how their products can be hacked," Hurley told TechNewsWorld.
Related Stories
Gateway Goes Gigabit, Wireless April 06, 2004
"Larger file sizes, Voice over IP and gigabit NICs in desktops and notebooks are all driving a fundamental change in organizations from 10/100 to gigabit speeds," said Scott Weinbrandt, senior vice president of Gateway's Enterprise Systems Division. "And it's critical that their network switches don't become bottlenecks."
The Myth of the Secure Operating System April 03, 2004
"Forget about the OS," Laura DiDio, senior analyst at the Yankee Group, told TechNewsWorld. "Don't even argue those merits. Every piece of software that is connected is potentially vulnerable and at risk."
Apple Delays Mini iPod's European Debut March 26, 2004
"Come July, there is still plenty of opportunity for Apple to leverage the demand for the Mini," The Mac Observer publisher Bryan Chaffin told the E-Commerce Times, noting that the delay likely will not hurt Apple's market position.
Apple Ships First Xserve G5s, Unveils Workgroup Clusters March 23, 2004
In general, commercial data centers are less inclined to change their existing setups and vendor agreements than research centers, Haff said, which may be one reason why Apple is having more success in the research space. However, members of the scientific community tend to be fickle buyers, which puts a great deal of pressure on Apple to keep up the performance of its server offerings, he added.
Apple's Ron Okamoto Previews WWDC 2004 March 17, 2004
"The technology base of the [OS X] operating system combined with the portability of our PowerBook line has really been a good marriage. And having the G5 processor is a good foundation for doing other things in the future," Apple VP Ron Okamoto told the E-Commerce Times.
Related News Alerts
More by Jay Lyman
Open Source Developer Dumps Novell Over Microsoft Deal December 26, 2006
A key open source developer, Jeremy Allison, who cofounded the Samba project, has resigned from Novell in protest over the company's recent agreement to enter a collaborative arrangement with Microsoft. The deal has created an uproar in the open source community because it does not treat all recipients of the GPL equally and thus violates the spirit of the license, critics say.
Financial Firms Tap Microsoft for Linux December 22, 2006
Three major financial institutions are among the first companies to go to Microsoft for Linux services, provided through an agreement the software giant struck with Novell. Although a recent survey showed customer approval of the collaboration, many members of the open source community view Novell's move as sleeping with the devil.
Mozilla Beefs Up Security in Firefox 2.0 December 21, 2006
Mozilla's latest update to its open source Firefox browser includes security measures targeting phishers. Phishing scams that use social engineering techniques to dupe Web surfers into revealing personal financial information have become an effective way for cybercriminals to conduct their nefarious activities on the Internet.