Welcome | Sign In
ECommerceTimes.com
Special Reports

Whatever Happened to Dot-Com Stunts?

Print Version
E-Mail Article
Reprints
Whatever Happened to Dot-Com Stunts?

Dot-com stunts were more often about brand-awareness overkill than about focused brand-building and strategic marketing.


Run Your Entire Contact Center in the Cloud
Many businesses are increasingly seeking ways to improve the quality, flexibility, and scalability of their traditional call centers. Download this free white paper and learn the top 8 reasons to consider going virtual.

Does anybody remember the DotComGuy? How about IUMA? Or even the e-Cavemen?

Last year, the Net was inundated with publicity stunts and name games aimed at driving Net-weary consumers online.

Have a new Web site to publicize? Sponsor a baby-naming contest, like IUMA.com did, paying new parents a few thousand bucks to name their new son or daughter after a dot-com.

Tired of working 9 to 5? Lock yourself in your house for a year, living solely off the Internet and watch the corporate sponsorships roll in -- or not -- in the fashion of DotComGuy.

It seemed like there would be no end to the creativity and scope of the e-commerce publicity stunts. But take a look throughout the dot-com landscape today and the only stunts you will find are companies managing to survive online with making a profit.

Goodbye To All That

What happened? Were these stunts victims of the overall economic downturn? Or were they inherently flawed? Both, say analysts.

"Public enthusiasm for the more gimmicky aspect of the Internet has gone way down for obvious reasons," IDC analyst Malcolm Maclachlan told the E-Commerce Times. "A lot of people have lost a lot of money. We're past the point where just attaching the word Internet to something makes it cool."

In addition, most of the dot-com stunts were performed by pure plays, which are now virtually extinct, said Yankee Group analyst Paul Ritter.

"The era of the dot-com stunt is over and it should be over," Ritter told the E-Commerce Times. "There is a correlation in peoples' minds that dot-com stunts are associated with dot-com failures. Pure play e-tailers particularly are a dying breed."

Too Much, Too Early

Moreover, dot-com stunts were based on what is now considered the taboo of e-commerce: brand advertising overkill.

"The stunts were merely a reflection of the attempts to gain brand exposure, and not about brand building," said Ritter.

Maclachlan believes that the decline of dot-com stunts is also related to an important lesson for Internet retailers that took some time to become clear.

"[The Internet] has shown itself to be more gimmick-proof than one-way mediums like TV or radio," Maclachlan said. "People searching the Net have greater consumer choice, and something without style or substance consumers are less likely to bother with and it's less likely to work now."

Hindsight Helps

But did dot-com publicity stunts work in the first place?

"With 20/20 hindsight, I don't think they worked," Ritter said. "As someone who covers the online retail Increase Customer Sales with Email Marketing -- Free Trial from VerticalResponse industry for a living, I don't know what the benefits of the DotComGuy were for any particular company. Even the Pets.com puppet didn't work."

Even if they did serve a purpose a year and a half ago, the stunts would serve no real purpose now, said Maclachlan.

"Did they work in beginning? Absolutely," Maclachlan said. "Any little stunt was probably worthwhile. But they can't work today because there's less people trying to launch companies now, and it's impossible to get financing."

Try, Try Again?

Of course, that does not mean companies still might not try a stunt or two in the future.

"In many cases it's not too expensive to try and do these kinds of stunts, which is why in some cases they were done in the first place," Ritter said. "They probably will be tried again, but I don't think with any significant or lasting impact."

As for those who still harbor dreams of becoming the next household Internet name, Maclachlan had the following advice:

"Calling yourself DotComGuy is probably a good way to get beat up on the street these days."


Print Version E-Mail Article Reprints More by Michael Mahoney


Talkback: Join the Discussion.
Re: Whatever Happened to Dot-Com Stunts?
mary
Posted 2001-12-31
One of the VOIP type new companies supposedly was giving away a BMW. About a year ago I'd get ...
Re: Whatever Happened to Dot-Com Stunts?
Randy
Posted 2001-11-16
interesting that Quixtar.com made over $816 million this last year with no advertising, a 57% ...
Re: Whatever Happened to Dot-Com Stunts?
Judy
Posted 2001-11-17
I heard that Surprise.com got a lot more traffic by paying for search engine optimization than ...

More by Michael Mahoney

How To Pinpoint Stellar Sellers Online
March 18, 2002
Even higher-margin items, such as fur coats or Oriental rugs, can be sold online if an e-tailer can wrap a brand name or additional services around them, Gaw said.
E-Commerce: Back and Bigger Than Ever?
March 08, 2002
To get a true read on the health of the e-commerce sector, observers should keep close tabs on several financial indicators, according to analysts.
Look Who's Making Money Online in 2002
February 14, 2002
It is no secret that travel works as a business on the Internet, mainly because online travel providers do not need to carry physical inventories.
Don't miss a story -- sign up for our FREE e-mail newsletters and view the latest headlines at a glance.
Tech News Flash [ View Sample ]
E-Commerce Minute [ View Sample ]
ECT News Network Weekly Newsletter [ View Sample ]
Shortcuts
ECT News Network Information
Reader Services
Corporate
ECT News Network