T-Mobile Gets Scrappy With Cheap VoIP Service
T-Mobile's VoIP service innovation -- currently in the testing phase in Seattle and Dallas -- may constitute a recognition that many mobile users still are not satisfied with the coverage and quality of service they can get in their homes, said JupiterResearch analyst Ina Sebastian.
02/21/08 2:24 PM PT
T-Mobile confirmed Thursday it is testing an Internet-based calling plan meant to replace traditional land lines, a move that came just a day after it joined key rivals in announcing a flat-rate mobile plan that could help change the economics of the wireless industry.
The new VoIP (Voice over Internet Protocol) service, Talk Forever, lets mobile customers pay an additional US$10 per month for unlimited at-home calling. It would require the users to purchase a router from T-Mobile, but the low price point could prove appealing.
The test is being run in Seattle and Dallas for the time being. A wider rollout may be necessary to ensure that the pure-wireless carrier will be able to compete effectively with rivals that offer bundled wireless, land line, broadband Internet and television services.
T-Mobile is the smallest of the four major wireless carriers in the U.S., behind Verizon, AT&T and Sprint Nextel. It is owned by Germany-based Deutsche Telecom. Given its position in the market, it is looking to innovate to avoid being trampled by its much-larger rivals.
In addition to leveling the playing field, T-Mobile's offering could pressure VoIP firms such as Vonage, whose own unlimited calling plan comes with a higher monthly price tag. Vonage's basic plan costs $25 per month.
T-Mobile began its expansion into land line territory last year. It rolled out a program that lets subscribers use a WiFi access point to make phone calls from home using their mobile phones -- but not burning plan minutes in the process.
The carrier has not disclosed adoption numbers for that service, known as "HotSpot@Home." It requires users to have a phone that can operate on both WiFi and traditional cellular networks, and such phones have seen limited adoption.
The new service would be something of a departure from the marketing campaigns that used "The Only Phone You Need" as a tagline. The VoIP innovation may constitute a recognition that many users still are not satisfied with the mobile coverage and quality of service they can get in their homes, said JupiterResearch analyst Ina Sebastian.
Other carriers have tried to address the same problem in different ways. For instance, Sprint and AT&T are offering cellular booster stations meant to improve signal reception in the home.
Landlines aren't going away any time soon, but "in particular, young users are more likely to want to use cell phones exclusively," Sebastian told the E-Commerce Times.
"Cellular coverage outside of the home is still most important, but pricing and in-home coverage follow close behind as two top priorities for cell phone users choosing a wireless provider," she added.
To get the $10 unlimited in-home calling plan, subscribers need to have a mobile plan worth at least $39 a month. They also need to purchase a $50 router from T-Mobile. Any traditional phone can be plugged into the converter and T-Mobile.
Last summer, T-Mobile filed plans with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) suggesting that it has been working on a VoIP offering for some time. The company has not said how long the Seattle and Dallas tests will run, or when it will make a decision about a possible national rollout of the service.
If it does add a second at-home calling option, T-Mobile will be underscoring the need to continually update offerings in order to keep mobile customers from wandering to rivals, especially those who have a broader menu of products and services, Forrester Research Analyst Charles Golvin told the E-Commerce Times.
"The competition is very fierce, and with number portability, moving has become easier," he said. Still, many of the top carriers have managed to reduce their churn, in part by adding features quickly to match or exceed those of rivals. "Carriers are working very hard to keep the playing field as level as possible."
That's inherently difficult for T-Mobile, because it lacks the land-line assets that most of its rivals still maintain, noted Golvin.
The move may be a harbinger of additional creative solutions to come. T-Mobile is expected to debut a more advanced wireless data service built on the wireless spectrum it won in an FCC auction in 2006.
The carrier tried to get ahead of the competition this week when all the major players -- except for Sprint -- unveiled flat-rate, all-you-can-eat monthly mobile plans. While AT&T and Verizon are offering unlimited calling for $99 per month, T-Mobile sweetened the deal by including unlimited instant messages, text messages and photo messages.
T-Mobile reported in January that it added more than 950,000 new subscribers in the fourth quarter, though it missed its own targets for all of 2007.