By Keith Regan E-Commerce Times
12/05/01 10:26 AM PT
At least one analyst remains skeptical that Amazon can succeed in the business of selling
electronics online, where so many pure-play e-tailers, including Egghead, have failed.
Improve Your Email Marketing Our proven and powerful email marketing solution offers exceptional deliverability, detailed analytics, a robust feature set, and superior service and support. Learn how you can enhance your email marketing program today. Download a free trial!
Amazon.com (Nasdaq: AMZN) said Tuesday it had bought all of
the assets of defunct e-tailer Egghead.com through a California bankruptcy court for
US$6.1 million.
Amazon submitted the winning bid for Egghead last week, Amazon spokesperson Patty Smith
said. By late Tuesday, visitors to the Egghead.com Web site, which has been running
though it stopped taking orders in late October, were being re-directed to Amazon's
electronics page.
There, a note tells visitors that Egghead and Amazon "are teaming
up to make it easier than ever to find the best in computers, electronics,
software, and much more. Shop today and check back for the exciting
re-launch of Egghead.com."
Privacy Matters
Smith told the E-Commerce Times that "Egghead is a very well-known and well-respected
brand, particularly in the Northwest." In fact, Egghead opened its first brick-and-mortar
store in Amazon's hometown of Seattle, Washington, in 1984.
"They have a very tech-savvy customer base and we think this is an opportunity to
combine the best of what Egghead offered their customers with what Amazon does best,
which is offering great selection, value and product information," Smith said.
Despite its financial woes, Egghead continued to record strong sales figures,
Smith noted, with $180 million in sales during the first three quarters of 2001.
Data Safe
The purchase includes the Egghead.com domain name and other intellectual property,
including Web site data. However, Amazon said it will not use Egghead's customer list,
which was guarded by the Menlo Park, California e-tailer's privacy policy requiring that
customers give prior consent before having their information used by a third party.
Smith noted that Egghead customers will have to re-enter their
information to become registered at Amazon.
"We of course intend to comply with all the commitments in that
privacy policy," she added.
Bargain Hunting
The price is a significant discount over the $10 million that Fry's Electronics had
offered to pay for the bulk of Egghead's assets in August. However, Egghead could not
close that deal and abruptly stopped taking orders on its site on October 25th, despite
its earlier pledge to continue operations during its bankruptcy proceedings.
"The price looks pretty reasonable in absolute terms, but $6 million
is significant for a company like Amazon," Morningstar.com stock
analyst David Kathman told the E-Commerce Times.
Amazon has pledged pro forma operating profits in the current quarter, he noted.
Egging Amazon On
"The bigger question is the future of Amazon's electronics store,"
Kathman said. While the Egghead deal is aimed at beefing up offerings
in that category, Kathman said he remains skeptical that Amazon
can succeed in a business where so many pure-play e-tailers,
including Egghead, have failed.
"In general Amazon has been very high on electronics, saying it's
going to be a great business which will make a lot of money for them.
I'm still waiting to be convinced," he said. "Amazon says they can do
it better, but so far they're still losing quite a bit of money in that
business. I'm going to remain skeptical until they show me that
they can make money doing this."
Scrambled Eggs
The Amazon purchase ends a long and strange odyssey for Egghead.
Founded as a traditional retailer of software in 1984 and eventually
growing to a chain of 84 stores in malls and urban areas across the U.S.,
Egghead swore off bricks and mortar to become an Internet pure play in 1998.
The strategy -- which flies directly in the face of the widespread belief
held today that a multichannel approach
is the most effective way to sell online --
held up for a while. In 1999, Egghead merged with fellow pure-play
OnSale.com in a deal said to be worth $400 million at the time.
But 2001 proved to be a fatal year for Egghead. Despite two
rounds of layoffs that claimed nearly 250 jobs and the extension
of a $20 million line of credit from IBM (NYSE: IBM) Global Financial, Egghead
found itself facing delisting from the Nasdaq. Eventually, the
e-tailer opted for bankruptcy protection.